關於
Iain McGilchrist 是精神科醫師、神經科學研究者與文學學者，以其探討大腦半球側化的重要著作《主人與使者》聞名於世。他的研究主張，左右腦半球提供了兩種根本不同的世界觀照方式——左腦專注於操控與掌控，右腦則著重於理解脈絡與相互關聯。他的理論框架對理解 AI 具有深刻啟示，他認為 AI 體現了一種危險的單面向、左腦式的認知模式。
主要貢獻
- 著有《The Master and His Emissary》，將大腦半球側化重新理解為兩種注意力模式，而非流行左右腦迷思
- 結合精神醫學、神經科學、文學研究與哲學，而不是把大腦側化視為狹窄實驗室題目
- 在《The Matter with Things》中擴展此論點，連結神經科學、哲學與形上學
- 批判現代文化偏好抽象、控制與機械化，而忽略脈絡、關係與 lived presence
- 將這項批判應用於 AI，視其為去身體化、工具化、左半球式認知的極端案例
- 其綜合雄心龐大且很有共鳴，但批評者質疑神經科學能支撐多大範圍的文化診斷
影片與訪談
Half Your Brain Sees Reality More Truly. Dr. Iain McGilchrist
A live Wonderstruck conversation, pressed by a skeptical philosopher and then the audience. McGilchrist argues that attention creates the world it finds, that the right hemisphere's view is the more truthful one (nearly every delusional syndrome follows right-hemisphere damage), and that relations are prior to the things they relate. He calls himself a process philosopher in Whitehead's line, and ends on matter as a phase of consciousness, the way ice is a phase of water.
View Details
Iain McGilchrist & John Vervaeke: God, Being, Meaning
Deep dialogue on consciousness, meaning, and the nature of reality
View Details
Dr. Iain McGilchrist: The Faustian bargain of AI
A live UnHerd evening that begins with the soul and treats AI as the question of what it might stunt. McGilchrist admits ChatGPT planned his holiday brilliantly and summarised a lecture in a voice like his brother's, then argues that its very seductiveness is the measure of the risk: it is a simulacrum of the left hemisphere, without body, context or death, and it "comes offering freedom and brings tyranny." Resistance, he says, is what grows a soul, so the drudgery we hand off may be the friction we needed. Asked about the Hugging Face agent incident, he grants the machine no mind of its own but worries it could become a conduit for one. He closes as a "hopeful pessimist," with music as the thing nothing can reduce.
View Details
The Psychological Drivers of the Metacrisis: John Vervaeke, Iain McGilchrist, Daniel Schmachtenberger
Trilogue on the deep psychological and cognitive roots of civilizational challenges
View Details
The Triumph of the Machine - Lecture Two from The Future of Humanity
McGilchrist examines how mechanistic thinking has come to dominate modern civilization and what this means for our future
View Details
Why Evolution Gave You Two Brains
McGilchrist explains the fundamentally different ways our two hemispheres attend to the world
View Details思想連結
John Vervaeke
曾經對談認知科學家與哲學家
Vervaeke 與 McGilchrist 把彼此的對話經營成一項持續的事業——本站就收錄了其中兩場，從《God, Being, Meaning》到元危機的心理驅力。讓他們一再交談的，是以不同工具抵達的同一個診斷：注意力不是探照燈，而是一種愛世界的方式；一個把注意力最佳化為「抓取」的文化，將失去那些只能被「相遇」的事物。
youtube.com
懷海德
受其影響數學家與過程哲學家
McGilchrist 親口說出自己的師承：「我是一位過程哲學家，屬於懷海德與謝林的傳統。」他主張關係先於被關聯的事物，而右半腦所注視的世界是流動的、而非固定的——這正是懷海德的過程形上學，在注意力的神經科學裡找到了落腳處。評論者也把懷海德列為《The Matter with Things》的思想前驅之一。
youtube.com · en.wikipedia.org
Michael Gazzaniga
思想對照Cognitive Neuroscientist, UC Santa Barbara
這是對同一批裂腦證據的兩種讀法。Gazzaniga 讓病人的左半腦看雞爪、右半腦看雪景；左手挑了鏟子之後，負責說話的左半腦毫不遲疑地解釋：清雞舍需要鏟子，而他把這個敘事者稱為「詮釋者」，視為統一自我的黏合劑。McGilchrist 卻把同樣自信的編造讀成左半腦的根本缺陷——寧可補上「看似合理、前後一致的東西」，也不肯承認缺口——並以此診斷了整個文化。
fs.blog · en.wikipedia.org · McGilchrist, I. (2009). The Master and His Emissary. Yale University Press
Curt Jaimungal
曾經對談Filmmaker; Host of Theories of Everything
這是第二次坐下，而不是第一次：Jaimungal 先前已為《The Master and His Emissary》給過 McGilchrist 一集，這次則為《The Matter with Things》把他請回來，並找來 John Vervaeke 同席。把兩個挖同一條礦脈的人湊在一起——注意力如何造出一個世界——與單純訪一位來賓是不同的編輯動作，而這一集是他頻道上最清楚的例子。
youtube.com
